Chocolate (#D2691E) and Smoky black (#100C08) appear together across 6 master palettes in our corpus, most prominently in the work of Johann Friedrich Overbeck, Azim Azimzade, and Mihaly Munkacsy and the Neo-baroque tradition. Painters typically deployed chocolate at an average of 23% of the canvas, with smoky black at 8%. Third colors most often completing the combination include Zinnwaldite brown (#2C1608), Seal brown (#59260B), and Bistre (#3D2B1F).