Café noir (#4B3621) and Smoky black (#100C08) appear together across 6 master palettes in our corpus, most prominently in the work of Roman Ribera Cirera, Antonio Maria Esquivel, and John Greenhill and the Baroque tradition. Painters typically deployed café noir at an average of 33% of the canvas, with smoky black at 27%. Third colors most often completing the combination include Zinnwaldite brown (#2C1608), Coyote brown (#81613C), and Khaki (#C3B091).